Dispatch: Chicago Fire (1) vs. New England Revolution (1)

Baky... (photo: goal.com)

Bakary Soumare did his job well on Saturday, to little avail (photo: goal.com)

OTF contributor T.J. Zaremba brings you “the Seinfeld Game”…

As I left Toyota Park Saturday afternoon after Chicago Fire tied the MLS record for consecutive ties, I thought of Seinfeld. Much like the game I witnessed, Seinfeld was a show about nothing. After I returned home, I hoped watching the game on TV would change my opinion. It did not. There is nothing to take away from this game that is new. In fact, what I saw will, I think, be the theme for this season: nothing very good, nothing very bad, just average.

Like the previous home game versus the Union, the Fire left two points on the table with a penalty kick miss in stoppage time. This time, it was a leftover Klopas folly rearing its ugly head: the waste of a Designated Player that is Juan Luis Anangonó, who took the honor of making a shit show out of a PK. Initially, I was encouraged that Anangonó took the ball and showed confidence in taking the PK. That was great to see. But his execution was nothing short of a disaster. Someone should have waved a skunk in front of that wasted opportunity.

Why the Fire do not have a designated taker of penalties is beyond me. Much like a basketball team has someone who takes its technical foul free throws, a soccer team should have someone who can step up and make a spot kick. This is something Frank Yallop needs to fix quickly. This shortcoming has meant four wasted points for a team that is not good enough to waste four points — if it has any ambition, that is.

On my way home from the match, I received an alert from the Fire on my phone that Quincy Amariwka was named Man of the Match. Thankfully, I was not driving, or I may have crashed. Though in Amarikwa’s defense, he scored a beautiful goal. Big Red Larentowicz did an excellent job to win the ball in the midfield and distribute it to Harry Shipp, whose through ball was a thing of beauty. Shipp hit his forward mate in stride, behind the defense, and Amarikwa put the ball where Revs ‘keeper Bobby Shuttleworth wasn’t.

However, after the goal, it was all downhill for the Fire’s spark plug. Certainly, you can debate the merit behind Amarikwa’s first yellow card. To me, there was nothing conclusive in person or on replay that shows whether Amarikwa was fouled or whether he initiated the contact. I am a referee with nearly 20 years of experience. As such, I think Sorin Stoica handled the situation perfectly. Stoica’s choice was to either award a penalty kick or issue a yellow card for simulation. He felt Amarikwa initiated the contact and punished him accordingly.

Lee Nguyen preserved the road point for the Revs by converting his PK (photo: espn.go.com)

Lee Nguyen preserved a road point for the Revs by converting his PK (photo: espn.go.com)

From that point forward, Amarikwa did nothing but lose his head. He was constantly whining, complaining, and looking for every call — which he did not deserve. Quincy needs to learn to stay on his feet and fight a bit, so when he does go down it will be seen as valid and not leave questions in the referee’s mind.

Amarikwa’s second yellow was simply stupid. His was a reckless challenge. To come in studs up like he did warranted a yellow card at the very least. Had Quincy received a straight red, it may have been considered harsh, but would also have been correct. A flying, studs up challenge at a player’s knee and ankle leads to nothing but bad stuff.

If any good came out of Amarikwa’s red card it was Mike Magee’s appearance to defend his teammate. I am not really sure what type of case Mike tried to put forth, but he made the effort nonetheless. Up to that point, I was convinced Magee was known as the “Magic” one for his ability to disappear. As Forrest Gump famously said, “And that’s all I have to say about that.”

One positive to take away from this match versus the Revs was the way the Fire responded after Amarikwa’s yellow card. Instead of bunkering down and trying to preserve the draw, Chicago, down to ten men, continued to take the game to New England. It was difficult to tell who was playing a man up during the final 15 or so minutes. As mentioned, notable team effort led to a well-earned, yet unsuccessful PK in the end.

Also on the bright side, Chicago’s in-game tactical adjustments made sense and yielded positive results. Yallop’s three subs helped keep the Fire the better team during the match. Effective on-the-fly decision making by the manager is a nice change from recent seasons.

For the most part, the Fire controlled the run of play on Saturday. With a successful PK, a 2-1 win would have been justified. Yet despite its statistical domination, Chicago was rarely more dangerous than New England on the afternoon, so perhaps the 1-1 draw is a fair result after all.

And so, after a sixth consecutive draw, the season about nothing continues…


Follow On The Fire’s new Twitter account @OTFSoccer


T.J. Zaremba was BarnBurner #110 and 1998 second-half season ticket holder in Section 8 of pre-mothership Soldier Field. After over a decade on walkabout, with a handful of guest appearances, he returned in 2011 and has been a regular (when his commitment to Uncle Sam allows it) at Toyota Park with his wife and the Hamster. Follow T.J. @TJZaremba

4 thoughts on “Dispatch: Chicago Fire (1) vs. New England Revolution (1)

  1. Gotta say I agree wholeheartedly with your comments. Despite the fact most of the fans around me were calling for blood – I also thought the ref got most of the calls right, and I was smart enough to keep my thoughts to myself.

    However, I absolutely disagree with your assessment that we need a designated penalty taker. No way on that – that is exactly the wrong thing to do.

    Shooting free throws is a bad analogy here because no one is guarding the basket. Hitting a clutch free throw is always tough but you are not competing against an opponent when you take one.

    It is the goal tender that changes the dynamics in a PK situation. With the keeper out of the picture I suspect (but I could be wrong) that even our DP would have scored on his pathetic attempt Saturday.

    At the professional level a designated PK is a horrible idea and is exactly the wrong thing to do – which is why I think the Fire don’t generally do it nor should they even consider it. The last thing this club needs is a designated scape-goat.

    In football, at the professional level at least, anybody should be able to hit the net on a PK a vast majority of the time – even our keeper should be able to it well. It should not be an issue. It will cease to be an issue when someone steps up and does his job – and nails one again – at least for a while.

    As you noted the Fire are not playing that bad. I too am disgusted by some stupid stuff that happened on the pitch Saturday as well, but I suspect this team may turn out to be much better than the results are showing at the moment.

  2. I’m glad that you mentioned that you were happy to see Anagano grab the ball and demand he take the kick. I know people are saying this is Larentowicz and Magee’s fault for not saying something but JLA was set on taking the PK. When it comes to taking PK’s I want a guy that has 100% confidence that he is going to make it and Anagano felt just that. He was set on taking it and I thought it was good to see our young DP finally stepping up. That being said, that PK was absolutely terrible and he should never take another PK again.

  3. All these points regarding the PK situation are well taken. I think what’s frustrating, though, is Larentowicz has demonstrated his ability to put an accurate, hard PK shot on frame.

    Magee, even when successful, is a bit too cute for my taste (Read: Panenka).

    JLA’s attempt was simply pathetic. I can’t remember ever seeing such a weakly-taken PK.

    Ultimately, I’ve got to agree with Coach Bob’s point that all professional players should be counted on to convert a penalty kick.

    Poor Yallop mustn’t be sleeping well right now. It’s gonna be a long bye-week. And with RSL up next, a nervous one at that.

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s